Thursday, September 27, 2012

The unexamined life is not worth living? and a modern day gadfly

Or so says Socrates. According to him, if you aren't constantly asking the big philosophical questions about life, and specifically your life, then what are you even doing still? Your life has no purpose. He didn't exactly say it in those words, but still. This is his argument for why we should all have philosophy, and all be questioning and examining. While I think that it's true that become more knowledgable and understanding things more fully sometimes leads to a more fulfilling life, I still do think that ignorance is bliss. Being happy with your lot in life and never questioning anything probably isn't morally satisfying for a lot of people. However, if it is, I say knock yourself out. I think a lot of us kind of wish we could be living in ignorance. Because while knowledge is power, a lot of the time it is also pain. I understand, however, that this isn't exactly what Socrates meant. He knows it can be painful, he shows that with the story he originally spoke of (although Plato wrote it down, yes), the Allegory of the Den. He knows that the unexamined life can be blissful and content, but it's still not worth living when you're not actually experiencing "Truth". But I'd still take contentedness over truth any day. Maybe one's existence is only a shadow of reality, but if it's a happy existence, I think it's worth living, and the choice of whether or not that person wants to take the risk of experiencing what is true and shaking that existence to the ground is their choice.

Okay, now for the second question. Who do I think is a modern-day gadfly? I suppose the person in my life who would most resemble that would be my father. Which is probably a sort of generic answer but I mean really, he's always questioning my brothers and I. He wants to make sure we're not blindly assuming or believing things that we haven't fully examined. Whenever I make a large statement about my beliefs or philosophy or otherwise, I become subject to thorough questioning and challenging from my father. It can be annoying sometimes, and it can shake me when he asks a question that I don't know how to answer, and then I have to rethink that statement. However, it's one of those "you'll thank me for this one day" deals, I'm pretty sure. It's caused me to be more wary of everything I'm told and everything I tell others.

2 comments:

  1. I think you made an excellent point about a shadow of reality still being a reality. Your optimistic view is inspiring, and your post was very coherent.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with what you are sayig about ignorance. I feel that it would be a lot easier to be happy believing in things that you want to. I know that I was a lot happier believing that Santa Clause existed than knowing he doesn't.

    ReplyDelete